This recipe is similar to a Fluffer Nutter This is very sugary and sticky. This should cure anyone with a sweet tooth.

2 Slices of Bread
Cherry Preserves
Miniature Marshamallows
Chocolate Morsels
Butter

Butter the 2 slices of bread and insert into the pie iron halves. Spread a thin layer of cherry preserves on each slice of bread. Add the miniature marshamallows and chocolates morsels to one slice of bread in a checkerboard pattern leaving some space between them for melting and oozing. Close and latch the pie iron and heat it until its golden brown.

It should cook up in about 4 – 5 minutes a side. Watch Out, the filling will be HOT!

Brian O.
Columbia, SC

Pie Iron Recipes

Amazon Pie Iron Cookbooks

Shop at Amazon,
All Proceeds from Sales
Support Pie Iron Recipes


Pie Iron Recipe Poll

Which Pie Iron do you use the most?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...